Sometimes your kids don’t want the truth

Remember the famous exchange in “A Few Good Men”?

Jack Nicholson: “You want answers?”

Tom Cruise: “I think I’m entitled to them.”

JN: “You want answers?”

TC: “I want the truth!”

JN: “You can’t handle the truth!”

I’ve been reading a fantastic book lately about World War II, Winter of the World, and my seven year old daughter, Claire, created a nightly ritual to ask me what is happening in my book during our bedtime routine.  “Daddy, tell me what is happening in your book?”

My answers have varied…”Daisy moved to London and into a big house”, “Carla met a boy named Werner and they danced to music in Germany”.  I’ve typically kept the subject matter of my nightly updates light and cheery.

The other night Claire asked about a certain character that I had mentioned a few nights prior.  “Well, remember I told you that there was a war going on between countries?  Joanne died in the war, sweetie.”

Claire stared at me and a moment later, a lone tear worked its way down her cheek.  She looked up at me with her big brown puppy dog eyes and said, “Daddy, I don’t want to hear about your book anymore.”  I assured her that I would keep the details of the book to myself.  Then I laid down next to her in bed for a few minutes, until she wanted to listen to music on her clock radio to help her fall asleep.

I sometimes forget that a seven year old girl still lives a world of ponies, princesses and sugary treats after dinner.  Yet she catches tidbits of the morning (not so positive) news on the TV.  She can read newspaper and magazine headlines and will ask questions about them.  She comes home from school and lectures me about fire safety and how I don’t have rope ladders in her and Grady’s bedroom.  Or I will overhear her explaining to Grady how they can never get into a car with a stranger.  How much does a 7 year old need to know about the real world?  Or put another way, how long can I (or should I) shield her from some of the realities of life?


2 thoughts on “Sometimes your kids don’t want the truth

  1. Great subject. We want our kids to stay kids and retain that innocence. But we also need our kids to know some reality to keep them safe, and we also don’t want to sanitize the world so they build no real coping skills.

    If our kid’s lives are filled with “bully free zones”, participation ribbons and validation for absolutely everything they do are they ever going to develop grit, toughness, thick skin or tenacity?

    Maybe not. Or maybe now is just not the time. It is a balancing act, and I’d submit that Dad’s that are actually asking these questions are the ones we least need to worry about coming up with the right answer.

  2. My comment Somes with the benefit of hindsight as I don’t know how I would have reacted in the moment in your situation. I have been trying to ask more questions of my kids in those situations so I understand their context and provide an opportunity to talk about tough topics. I don’t have the answer on what is the right balancing act but I think it is great if she is talking to her parents about this or any other tough topic. I would encourage you to not end the ritual of talking to her about books you are reading.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s